Dan
Brown
Curiously
i had recently read on-line that this was the most borrowed book in
libraries last year when i happened to see it in the local library,
so i picked it up; after all,
i enjoyed each of Brown's other books, though they were formulaic, so
why not this one? I am now in a position to answer that question:
Because it is more farcical than believable, more ridiculous than
clever, more pointless than a broken pencil. Because i enjoyed his
previous books, though they were, to an extent, predictable, and
because i respect his success (both financial and on my strict,
single criterion) i regret having to write this review, but The
Lost Symbol was
laughable; literally, at points during it, i was laughing ~ from
embarrassment at how bad it was, at the ridiculous things he was
expecting me to accept, at the mistakes of fact he made, at the
absurd ways his characters behaved in order to further his plot
twists.
When
i started reading the book i really had to work quite hard to get
into it; indeed, it has been three weeks since i took it out of the
library, and i started it the day i took it out. I felt guilty
because i was not being gripped by the story, desperate to turn the
pages, as i had been when reading his other works. It was not until
well over halfway through that i felt i was going to be able to make
it to the end: Though i knew intellectually i would, as i do with
practically every book i start, i didn't know it emotionally, i
wasn't excited about reading it. Because of my previous experience,
i confess that i thought there was something wrong with me, with mine
understanding, mine involvement. I was clearly, very mistaken.
There was something wrong, all right, but it was with Brown and his
book, not me. Sadly, this sequel is an absolute indictment of the
idea that because one book has been successful, another in the same
vein must be, too. Certainly it was popular when it came out, i
remember the displays; i bet, however, if he were to write another
about Robert Langdon not half the people that read this one would
rush to pick it up ~ assuming that, like me, they felt it was, rather
than a can't put it down, a can't pick it up book. Brown should have
stopped after The Da
Vinci Code, while he
was ahead.
No comments:
Post a Comment